ten10 Projects
To achieve perfect aim, just shoot then call anything you hit as target.
Friday, June 18, 2010

Noise Levels in Watch Winders

One of the key features that buyers look for when choosing a watch winder is the noise it generates.


To give you my opinion, there’s no such thing as a “Noiseless” (silent) winder. Instead of referring to them as “No Noise”, I would say its “Low Noise”. Noise is very subjective. There’s no standard noise level for winder manufacturers to benchmark with. Noise to one person is tolerable to another.

A German company who makes the UB1-6 winder unit measures it at 1m away and a noise level of between 30 ~ 50dbA was measured. Is this acceptable as compared to a Rapport unit? I think we’re comparing apples to oranges because both differ in design and work on different drive systems.

The UB1-6 is an open-type winder while the Rapport units are enclosed in a housing. Even if one were to compare enclosed units of, say, Rapport and Orbita the results would again be incomparable because both use different methods to rotate your watches.

Somehow, if the unit emits a grinding noise that is different from the day it came, the unit is noisy! One example I’ve seen and heard is from a YouTube contributor whose winder unit is about to breakdown. You can see the turntable struggling to rotate the watch with grinding sounds.


Noise (sound) will be generated by the winder because of
a) the gears inside the motor, (it’ll make a difference using polymer or metal gears),
b) the materials used for the housing that vibrates with the motor (it’s a soundbox),
c) the low torque of the motor struggling to carry the whole weight of the watch, and,
d) the poor construction of the winder, resulting in rubbing noises of the turntable.


It’s best to test the winder prior purchase for “noise” if you’re particular about it. The noise level should be at one’s accepted level with the unit door closed and listen from 2ft. away. This would be a fair way to test all winders. I’m very certain all winders should pass.

The problem does not come immediately but 3 to 6 months later after purchase. And hopefully your warranty doesn’t expire then. This is a common problem for cheap watch winders. You’re lucky if the unit is not a lemon. Buyers always want all the technical marvels and yet pay low price for a winder unit. You get what you paid for. And don’t be impressed with just the glossy exterior and fancy winding sequences it can do. It’s the insides that count too!

The Rotowind system by Orbita is the best option if you are a light sleeper and want to keep your timepiece in the bedroom. Otherwise any winder would do. If you hear whirls and hums, just place a pillow over your ears or your watch winder in a safe, the next room or in a locked closet and your problems are over.

Labels:


posted at 2:32 AM by ten10


My Profile

Archives

Sep 28, 2009
Sep 30, 2009
Oct 4, 2009
Oct 7, 2009
Oct 11, 2009
Oct 14, 2009
Oct 17, 2009
Oct 18, 2009
Oct 20, 2009
Oct 23, 2009
Oct 26, 2009
Oct 29, 2009
Nov 2, 2009
Nov 6, 2009
Nov 10, 2009
Nov 13, 2009
Nov 16, 2009
Nov 20, 2009
Nov 23, 2009
Nov 27, 2009
Dec 1, 2009
Dec 4, 2009
Dec 7, 2009
Dec 10, 2009
Dec 18, 2009
Dec 24, 2009
Jan 3, 2010
Jan 8, 2010
Jan 12, 2010
Jan 16, 2010
Jan 20, 2010
Jan 22, 2010
Jan 27, 2010
Feb 1, 2010
Feb 5, 2010
Feb 18, 2010
Feb 24, 2010
May 3, 2010
May 8, 2010
May 12, 2010
May 17, 2010
May 31, 2010
Jun 5, 2010
Jun 9, 2010
Jun 13, 2010
Jun 18, 2010
Jun 22, 2010
Jun 27, 2010
Jul 4, 2010
Jul 9, 2010
Jul 29, 2010
Aug 8, 2010
Aug 12, 2010
Aug 19, 2010
Aug 31, 2010
Sep 4, 2010
Sep 9, 2010
Sep 22, 2010
Sep 25, 2010
Sep 28, 2010
Oct 1, 2010
Oct 9, 2010
Oct 14, 2010
Oct 15, 2010
Nov 5, 2010
Nov 14, 2010
Nov 19, 2010
Nov 28, 2010
Nov 30, 2010
Jan 17, 2011


home

Recent Entries

The Mystery of Turns Per Day
JOIN ME
Circuit for AC Watch Winder
Part 3, Special Watch Display - The Housing
Form, Fit and Function of a Watch Winder
Part 2, Special Watch Display - The "Sensor" Circuit
Blog Break
Panerai Watches on Watch Winders
There's Technology inside a Watch Winder
DIY Watch Collector's Box


Sites I Visit

All About Circuits
Chad the Watch Guy
Chronocentric
Circuits Today
Complaints Board
Dardel Paris
DIY Electronic Projects
Electronic Circuits Projects
Electronic Zone
Electronics Projects
Fratellowatches
Horology Zone
Horozima
MetkuMods
Paneristi
Perpetuelle
Public Warehouse
RED Free Circuits
Talking Electronics
World of Time
Carbon Watch Winder


Watch Winders

Abest
Arcera
Brown Safe
Buben & Zorweg
Cradle of Time
Dottling
Eilux
Elma Motion
ERS/Bocano
Erwin Sattler
MTE
Orbita
Penelop
Rapport
Roytec, China
Scatola DelTempo
Swiss Kubik
UB Sammerl
Underwood
Wolf Designs


Credits

design by maystar
powered by blogger